Bug 219394 - [BISECTED][REGRESSION] WIFI Hotspot broken by commit 5c38bedac16
Summary: [BISECTED][REGRESSION] WIFI Hotspot broken by commit 5c38bedac16
Status: CLOSED WILL_NOT_FIX
Alias: None
Product: Drivers
Classification: Unclassified
Component: network-wireless-intel (show other bugs)
Hardware: All Linux
: P3 normal
Assignee: Default virtual assignee for network-wireless-intel
URL: https://github.com/lakinduakash/linux...
Keywords:
Depends on:
Blocks:
 
Reported: 2024-10-17 12:14 UTC by Jingyuan Deng
Modified: 2025-03-28 05:46 UTC (History)
5 users (show)

See Also:
Kernel Version: 6.11
Subsystem:
Regression: Yes
Bisected commit-id: 5c38bedac16a946402b627621b3d4bfcc9952479


Attachments

Description Jingyuan Deng 2024-10-17 12:14:41 UTC
Although full support of multi-channel may not be available for `iwlwifi` , multi-channel operation is helpful for some special services like hotspot. For example, it is possible to use multi-channel operation to create Hotspot at the same time connected to a WIFI AP. See https://github.com/lakinduakash/linux-wifi-hotspot for details.  

Commit 5c38bedac16a946402b627621b3d4bfcc9952479 bans multi-channel operation for `iwlwifi`. So that such Hotspot is not available anymore. See https://github.com/lakinduakash/linux-wifi-hotspot/issues/435 for details.   

I suggest thinking about some revision not to ban multi-channel operation totally.
Comment 1 Emmanuel Grumbach 2024-10-22 06:18:27 UTC
You should be using p2p_group_add instead of adding a hotspot.
You'll get the same feature set, but then, you'll be able to add the GO because we'll be allowed to use the Notice Of Absence.
Comment 2 Emmanuel Grumbach 2024-10-22 06:21:00 UTC
I am closing this since it is not a bug on the wifi side and there is a solution to keep your use case working: not using hostapd, but rather using p2p_group_add command in wpa_supplicant.
Comment 3 Gabriel Mantei 2025-01-18 22:35:36 UTC
I'm sorry to come in late, but by now I use a kernel on my distribution (manjaro) that is affected by this change. I want to argue, that wifi-p2p doesn't give the same features as a hotspot and isn't even supported for dumb linux users like me. When looking at android and windows (and I would guess apple too), they have a prominent feature to open a hotspot even if the single wifi-adapter is already connected to a network. The option for wifi-p2p / Wifi Direct is well hidden. On linux there are no guis for p2p available. As recommended I tried to get wifi-p2p working and jumped through a lot of hoops. But I couldn't get my linux pc connect to an android phone and am even further away from a wifi bridge. Please see some of the steps I tried. This is not a call for support, rather an example that wifi-p2p isn't supported (yet?) on linux desktops. But if someone wants to get me going again in my course to setup a wireless bridge with wifi-p2p, I'm happy to hear.
> 
> 
>* wifi bridge works on this machine with linux-wifi-hotspot and kernel 6.6
>* I was loosely following this 9 year old post [1]
>* I was trying to understand [2] but didn't
>* I can connect my android to another android via Wifi Direct
>* firewall, dnsmasq.conf, interface capabilities should all check out
>* I can see the connection attempts on the phone, but none go through to a
>working connection
> 
>```
>uname -r             # returns 6.12.4-1-MANJARO
>sudo dnsmasq
> 
>nmcli con add type wifi-p2p peer mac:aa:of:phone autoconnect no ipv4.addresses
>>192.168.12.1/24 ipv4.method manual
>nmcli con up wifi-p2p
># not working
> 
>### new attempt
>echo 'ctrl_interface=/var/run/wpa_supplicant
>ap_scan=1
>device_name=My-pc
>device_type=1-0050F204-1
>driver_param=use_p2p_group_interface=1' > /home/user/wpa_supplicant.conf
>nmcli radio wifi off
>rfkill unblock wlan
>sudo wpa_supplicant -Dnl80211 -iwlp3s0 -c/home/user/wpa_supplicant.conf
>sudo wpa_cli
> > p2p_find
> > p2p_peers             # returns mac:aa:of:phone
> > p2p_connect mac:aa:of:phone 45629034 display persistent
>sudo ip addr add 192.168.12.1/24 dev p2p-wlp3s0-0
># connected but disconnected after several seconds
> 
>### another attempt 
>sudo wpa_supplicant -Dnl80211 -iwlp3s0 -c/home/user/wpa_supplicant.conf
>sudo wpa_cli
> > p2p_find
> > p2p_peers             # returns mac:aa:of:phone
> > p2p_connect mac:aa:of:phone 45629034 wps_pbc
>sudo ip addr add 192.168.12.1/24 dev p2p-wlp3s0-0
># android responds, but can't get over 'CTRL-EVENT-EAP-FAILURE'
> 
>### again
>sudo wpa_supplicant -Dnl80211 -iwlp3s0 -c/home/user/wpa_supplicant.conf
>sudo wpa_cli -i wlp3s0 p2p_group_add
>sudo ip addr a 192.168.12.1/24 dev p2p-wlp3s0-0
>sudo wpa_cli
> > p2p_find
> > p2p_peers             # returns mac:aa:of:phone
> > p2p_connect mac:aa:of:phone 45629034 display persistent
># fails with error 'Failed to create interface p2p-wlp3s0-0: -23 (Too many
>open files in system)'
>```
> 
I'm not sure whether all of this is valid from a kernel point of view, but I still hope that the repeater/hotspot usecase can get enabled again either in kernel or as a user application for wifi-p2p.
> 
>[1](https://stackoverflow.com/questions/31877144/how-to-set-up-a-wifi-direct-connection-between-android-and-linux)
>[2](https://w1.fi/cgit/hostap/tree/wpa_supplicant/README-P2P)
Comment 4 kingwingshit 2025-02-04 19:44:47 UTC
I just registered to comment on this problem. 

Arch Linux's pacman just updated to linux-6.12.12-1, and my create_ap does not work while connecting to a WiFi. 

In my case, I run samba(smb) to share files on 192.168.12.0/24 only as well as port 22 for speed and security.
Comment 5 dipperstan09 2025-03-28 05:46:45 UTC
stuck in Arch 6.10.10 because i cant, for the life of me, successfully use the suggested "p2p_group_add". its probably skill issue but i am really hoping this feature will come back because its really useful for some cases.

Note You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.