Created attachment 276207 [details]
Initramfs unpacking failed: uncompression error
Since 4.17-rc1 my Asus X205TA (baytrail platform) often hangs on boot, when this happens I need to hard reset the laptop. I've looked for similar bugtrackers and there are some:
Black screen every 1/3 times on boot
screen stays dark for long on bootup since kernel 4.17.0-rc2+
black screen irrespective of amdgpu.dc=1 or 0 at boot on kernels 4.17-rc2 and onwards caused by low entropy
The first one being the most similar in describing the symptoms. But neither one of the recommended solutions (generating entropy on boot, enabling kasan memory debugger) helped for me.
I noticed while on ubuntu with the mainline kernel 4.17-rc1 that sometimes instead of a black screen I got an actual screendump of what went wrong (I've attached pictures). The errors are always slightly different but all point to initramfs decompression issues. So I started looking at the diff between 4.16 and 4.17-rc1 and reverted the commits to head_64.S (and for the compilation to succeed also the commits to pgtable_64.c). This 'solves' or rather circumvents the boot hangs for me. This workaround still works on 4.17-rc6.
Created attachment 276209 [details]
Initramfs unpacking failed: junk in compressed archive
Created attachment 276211 [details]
Initramfs unpacking failed: broken padding
This does not seem to be related to KASAN/sanitizers.
Sorry, I couldn't find a suitable category. I must have missed 'other'. Thanks for amending.
Hm. Could you try to bisect which commit is first broken one?
Either the commit for head_64.S in 4.17-rc1:
or the commit for pgtable_64.c in 4.17-rc1:
I can't successfully compile the kernel with only the first commit reverted.
That's not commits. That's just diffs between v4.16 and v4.17-rc1 for these files. It doesn't help much with isolating the problem.
Could you find the first broken *commit*.
This would give the list of commits to look at:
git log --no-merges --oneline v4.16..v4.17-rc1 arch/x86/boot/compressed
And have you checked that plain 4.17-rc6 or -rc7 are still broken? There was couple of fixes in v4.17-rc6 in this area.
Thanks for the pointers, sorry I'm not too savvy with git but I'm trying to learn.
When head is at:
d6289f36aa7d (HEAD) x86/build: Don't pass in -D__KERNEL__ multiple times
loading the initramfs never freezes.
When head is at:
07344b15a994 (HEAD) x86/boot: Fix SEV boot failure from change to __PHYSICAL_MASK_SHIFT
loading the initramfs freezes regularly.
I checked 07344b15a994 with git show, but there doesn't seem to be anything regarding head_64.S or pgtable_64.c in there. However the following commit (194a9749c73d) pertains arch/x86/boot/compressed/head_64.S
Is this the commit that causes the random freezes during initramfs load ?
Forgot to add: I've tried 4.17-rc6 en 4.17-rc7 and 4.17.0-rc7-next-20180529 and they all exhibit the same freezing behaviour.
Could you also check if 547edaca247a works fine for you?
No the initramfs also fails to load sometimes when booting a kernel compiled with head at:
547edaca247a (HEAD) x86/mm: Update comment in detect_tme() regarding x86_phys_bits
Issue still occurs with 4.18-rc1