Latest working kernel version:no one Earliest failing kernel version:my first was 2.6.18 Distribution:ubuntu Hardware Environment:asus p5wdh asus en8500gt c2d 4500 ddr2 800 2 go Software Environment:hardy 8.04 Problem Description:That mobo don't boot correctly with 2.6.24-16 (ubuntu hardy) https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux/+bug/212834 https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux/+bug/218079 https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux/+bug/211346 i need these grub options: irqpoll & noprobe=ata4 to boot Steps to reproduce:
urgh. You have x86 and ata and possibly PCI and acpi problems all rolled into the one report. Oh well. I randomly reassigned it to i386.
hi, i'm using generic kernel, not i386 what i have found: the kernel boot might know that the chipset Sil4723 linked on sata2 port is not an ata device and has not any device plugged on it . So, the kernel might check: 1) what is or not a chipset ? 2) what is or not a device ? 3) after this step, is a device plugged or not ?, if not don't try to find one. Hopping this can help !!!
Aieee... My favorite p5wdh again. Setting ahci mode should work around the problem. I'll see whether I can make ata_piix mode work too.
Created attachment 16041 [details] p5wdh-debug.patch Can you please apply the attached patch and test the followings? * It works fine w/o hard disk attached to the 4726 port in ahci mode * It works fine w/ hard disk attached to the 4726 port in ahci mode * It works fine w/o hard disk attached to the 4726 port in ata_piix mode * It works fine w/ hard disk attached to the 4726 port in ata_piix mode
thanks for all that job, as i don't know how to apply this patch, please give me the way. before to do that, i must say i have made some changes since the report bug: working with a dual boot, i found how to tell xp to work with ahci mode; so now booting is easier and close normal: irqpoll and noprobe=ata are no more needed. but, lspci -vvnn still recognize and other mobo than mine : Subsystem: ASUSTeK Computer Inc. P5WDG2 WS Professional motherboard [1043:8178] More updated details on launchpad.
Created attachment 16239 [details] 1 sata drive, 1 IDE drive, AHCI on, ATA4 error
Created attachment 16240 [details] 1 sata drive, 1 IDE drive, AHCI off, ATA4 error
Created attachment 16241 [details] 2 sata drive, AHCI off, 2nd Sata on ATA4, no ATA4 error
I really need someone to test 2.6.25.4 + patch from comment #4. Can anyone do that please?
It works!!. P5W DH Deluxe(bios 2602. SATA as IDE Enhanced mode + gentoo-source 2.6.25-r4) patch(p5wdh-debug.patch) ok. no boot delay!!! GREAT!!!
Thanks for verifying. Patch already scheduled for upstream. Resolving as FIXED.