Most recent kernel where this bug did not occur: Distribution:Debian sid Hardware Environment:PPC Software Environment: Problem Description:There is no (kismet) source to use it. This is just a reminder for Danial Drake, Steps to reproduce:None
Pretty sure no source is needed, just WEXT. However there have been several reports that kismet doesn't agree with ZD1211's policy on channel changing.
Ulrich: iw_set_freq() in zd_netdev.c does this: u8 channel; r = zd_find_channel(&channel, freq); if (r < 0) return r; r = zd_mac_request_channel(mac, channel); zd_find_channel() in zd_ieee80211.c does this: int zd_find_channel(u8 *channel, const struct iw_freq *freq) { int i, r; u32 mhz; if (!(freq->flags & IW_FREQ_FIXED)) { return 0; } So, when IW_FREQ_FIXED is set, zd_find_channel returns 0 and does not modify channel. We then pass some uninitialized value to zd_mac_request_channel(). This is bad. In my tests this usually makes it end up requesting channel 177 which is not part of the regdomain so it gets rejected from inside zd_mac_request_channel(): if (!zd_regdomain_supports_channel(mac->regdomain, channel)) { spin_unlock_irqrestore(&mac->lock, lock_flags); return -EINVAL } This is why kismet is failing. Source 0 (eth3): Enabling monitor mode for bcm43xx source interface eth3 channel 6... FATAL: Failed to set channel 6 22:Invalid argument kismet makes no effort to set the flags attribute of the request, it leaves it as 0. I've done some reading of this thread: http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?t=114518684400001&r=1&w=2 And the whole fixed vs auto thing really isn't clear to me, but I'll post a first attempt at a fix shortly...
Changed my mind slightly. I found the description of "iwconfig freq auto" in the iwconfig man page. I guess the behavior is expected to be something like: In monitor mode, auto is meaningless, you'd only ever accepted fixed plus a frequency to change to. In managed mode, all SIWFREQ calls would be rejected In ad-hoc mode before cell join/creation, SIWFREQ is accepted as fixed plus a frequency, or "auto" in which case it might find the quietest channel (or reject it) In master mode, SIWFREQ is accepted as fixed plus a frequency, or "auto" in which case it might find the quietest channel (or reject it) Given that our current implementation of IW_FREQ_AUTO is incomplete and broken, I think we should drop it for now. We could always implement a true AUTO scheme later, although it is really something that should be done in userspace, plus we have a new 802.11 stack and configuration mechanism under development... The next question is: should we reject AUTO or simply ignore it? I think we should ignore it, like all other wireless drivers do (yes, not one in-kernel driver has IW_FREQ_AUTO support). This has the added advantage that kismet will work. At the same time, it is clearly a kismet bug that it is not setting flags to IW_FREQ_FIXED.
Created attachment 9541 [details] zd1211rw patch Ignore flags in SIWFREQ and GIWFREQ
Created attachment 9542 [details] kismet patch use IW_FREQ_FIXED flag when changing channel I'll send this to the kismet maintainer tomorrow
Tried both with nos success. Kismet isn't crashing anymore but I can't get my zd1211 device in monitoring mode and kismet didn't recognize sort changing. I've tried the zd1211 kismet source on 2.6.19-rc6
Please provide actual info - what are the error messages? Which commands are you using? And try the bcm43xx source.
Patch is now in wireless-dev and netdev trees